His path to professional baseball was aided by longtime Aggie head coach Tom Chandler. The 26-year A&M skipper served as the signing scout for the Cleveland Indians as they picked Magallanes in the 10th round of the 1987 MLB Draft.
“Coach Chandler called me,” Magallanes said. “He said ‘Hey, buddy, we got you. We got you in the 10th round.’ And I said ‘I’m happy to be an Indian. I’m ready to play.’”
His climb to the Major Leagues took the expected route. Two solid seasons of Single-A ball with the Kinston Indians in 1987 and ’88 as well as a 1989 summer with promotions to Double-A and Triple-A. He spent the entire 1990 season with the Triple-A Colorado Spring Sky Sox, where he enjoyed an outstanding year. He batted .308 with 60 runs, 17 doubles, three triples, one home run and 63 RBI in 125 games.
After starting 1991 in Triple-A, Magallanes got the call he’d been waiting for his whole life in the middle of May.
At the time, the wheels were off the wagon for the Indians. They sputtered out of the gate for an 11-19 start on the way to what would be a 57-105 campaign.
“It wasn’t a good time there for the Indians,” Magallanes said. “When I first got called up it was a weird experience. They had the most transactions in the big leagues that year. Guys were getting called up and sent down all the time. When I walked in the clubhouse, instead of congratulating me right away, a lot of the guys were wondering who was going to be sent down or released next. But after I got settled in they were great.”
He made his debut on May 17, 1991. The Tribe was taking on a juggernaut Oakland Athletics team that featured a trio of future Hall of Famers in Dennis Eckersley, Rickey Henderson and Harold Baines, as well as the Bash Brothers, Jose Canseco and Mark McGwire.
On a chilly evening in cavernous Cleveland Municipal Stadium, Magallanes took the field as a defensive replacement at shortstop with Chief Wahoo’s charges leading the A’s, 11-3. He got his first plate appearance in the bottom of the eighth, drawing a walk off of John Briscoe.
“Once I waked out on the field, it was like ‘Wow,’” Magallanes said. “It was an awesome experience. Something I’ll never forget.”
Alan Cannon, Texas A&M Associate Athletics Director and longtime Aggie Baseball sports information director, described Magallanes as the smoothest of operators at shortstop.
“It was uncanny,” Cannon said. “It didn’t matter how fast the hitter was. Ever would always get the throw to first base to beat the runner by a step.”
Magallanes’ stint in the Majors dispelled Cannon’s observation of “always beating the runner by a step.” In his MLB debut, his first play on defense Magallanes fielded a grounder from Henderson, who is on the Mount Rushmore of MLB speed merchants with the likes of Maury Wills, Lou Brock and Willie Wilson.
“Rickey came up and he hit a ground ball pretty much right at me,” Magallanes said. “It was Rickey Henderson! So, I had shortened up a little bit, respecting his speed. It’s a routine ground ball, probably a three-hopper, I charged it and grabbed it and you know, I threw it and got rid of it as quick as I could. I look up and Rickey’s not even on the cut of the grass. He’s probably 10 feet from first and he’s just cruising. He’s not even running hard. I walk into the dugout and everyone is kind of laughing and saying stuff like ‘Dude, why did you rush the throw?’ My first grounder in the Majors. I wasn’t going to let him beat it out (laughing).”
He would see action in two more games, spending 11 days with the big league club. Despite the brief stint, Magallanes joined an elite club. Since the dinosaurs have roamed the earth, less than 20,000 people have played Major League Baseball. And of that group, nearly 1,000 have played in just one game.
As is often the case, Major League dreams depend on a lot of luck. The future of the Indians’ infield featured names like Carlos Baerga, Felix Fermin and 1988 MLB Draft No. 2 overall pick Mark Lewis. So Magallanes looked for other places to catch on, spending 1992 in the Chicago White Sox organization and 1994-95 with the Texas Rangers farm system. He enjoyed relative success, including hitting .320 in 88 games between Double-A and Triple-A in 1993, but never got back to the Show.
That’s when Magallanes would return to his native Mexico where he would play from 1995-2005, including the first seven seasons with the Monterrey Sultanes.
“After I started playing in Mexico, there were a few offers to come back and be a spring training invitee,” Magallanes said. “Battle for a spot on the Triple-A team and be there to maybe get called back to the Majors. After I settled in down in Mexico, it really didn’t interest me. I started making some pretty good money in Mexico – tax-free money. They paid for my apartment. You make a decent living down there. You know what I said? ‘Nah. I’m just going to play here. I’m going to ride it out here.’”
In his first two seasons with Monterrey, the Sultanes claimed Serie del Rey titles. He also played for the Tabasco Olmecas in 2003 and wrapped up his career spending two campaigns with the Oaxaca Guerreros, playing his final season in 2005 at age 39.
“I was blessed to stay healthy and be able to enjoy a lengthy career,” Magallanes said. “I have no regrets. It was fun playing down there year-round and I was able to save up some money. That really helps when you’re first trying to break in as a coach.”
Enjoying the stability of a playing career in Mexico, Magallanes immersed himself in the sport, playing year-round. He would star repeatedly in one of the most pressure-packed baseball environments – The Caribbean Series.
“The atmosphere is like none other,” Magallanes said. “You can ask players that have played winter ball and they’ll tell you about the pressures of playing in the Caribbean World Series. It’s a different kind of pressure than playing in the majors because most of the guys are playing for their home country. It makes you play at a different level. There’s more at stake. There’s pride. You see the players on the other side like Roberto Alomar and Bernie Williams and Pudge Rodriguez. You see those guys and you want to beat them and put your name in the record books. It definitely raises your level of play.”
Magallanes would play in four Caribbean Series, batting .358 in 24 games. In 1996, he helped Culiacan Tomateros claim the title, the first-ever for the club and just the third for a squad from the Mexican Pacific League which began sending teams to the tournament in 1971. He was named the tournament’s All-Star second baseman in 1997 when he batted .526 (10-for-19) with nine runs, a home run and two RBI, beating out future MLB Hall-of-Famer Roberto Alomar.
“If I ever need to pat myself on the back or brag a little bit, I can bring that up,” Magallanes chuckled. “Puerto Rico had a dream team that year and Roberto was playing second base. But I played some really great baseball that week and got picked for the all-tournament team over Roberto who was at his peak at the time. It was a surreal experience.”
He earned his second Caribbean Series All-Star accolade in 1999, batting .381 with seven RBI in six games.
His outstanding play in Mexico and at the Caribbean Series earned Magallanes a spot as one of 101 players in the Caribbean Baseball Hall of Fame when he was installed as part of the 2013 class. The list of distinguished members includes MLB Hall of Famers Tony Perez, Rod Carew, Willie Mays, Edgar Martinez, Alomar and Roberto Clemente as well as renowned baseball dignitaries Minnie Minoso, Fernando Valenzuela, David Concepcion, Juan Gonzalez, Bernie Williams and Tony Pena.
“I was so honored when they told me, but I thought they were joking,” Magallanes said. “I’m like ‘Who? What? Who is this? You guys joking around?’ Seriously, I was waiting. I paused for a bit and then I said thank you. I hung up and told my wife. She said “You played so well. And they know it.” I never even thought about the numbers and how well I did average-wise and all that. And you know what? I did do some pretty good things. I recall I got some good hits and played solid defense. It was just a surreal experience and it didn’t hit me until the actual ceremony. My wife was pregnant at the time, so she didn’t travel but I got to be there with my dad and brother. It was a humbling experience and an incredible honor.”
As his playing career was winding down, Magallanes turned an eye toward coaching. He starting taking a more holistic view of the sport and developing his philosophy.
“Probably the last four years of my career playing I would be thinking in games ‘This is what I would do if I managed’,” Magallanes said. “That’s sort of how the thinking transitions. You start thinking what you would do in different situations if you were the manager. I was fortunate enough that a spot opened up with the Angels when I was ready to retire.